How does failure normalization foster product innovativeness in new product development? The role of passion and learning
Xiangming (Tommy) Tao, Deniz Ucbasaran
kHUB post date: March 2025
Originally published: 11 July 2024 (PDMA JPIM • Vol. 42, Issue 2 • March 2025)
Read time: 55 minutes
ACCESS THE FULL ARTICLE
Tolerating failure has gained recognition as a crucial catalyst for product innovation. However, there is a limited understanding of how and under what conditions project leaders' perceptions of failure normalization—the norms regarding failure in their work environment—can enhance product innovativeness in the context of new product development (NPD). Drawing upon sensemaking and motivation theories, we propose a moderated mediation model to address this research gap. Data were collected from 181 high-tech ventures in China, with responses gathered at three different time points from matched respondents. Utilizing moderated path analysis and the Monte Carlo method, our findings reveal that failure normalization primarily fosters product innovativeness by facilitating learning from failure. Importantly, this positive effect is contingent upon the project leader's passion for inventing. A profound passion for inventing significantly enhances NPD leaders' motivation to learn from failures, thereby acting as a pivotal factor that determines whether failure normalization promotes or impedes product innovativeness. This research thus elucidates the previously inconclusive relationship between failure normalization and product innovativeness as presented in the literature. It underscores the dual importance of organizational culture (specifically, failure normalization) and individual motivation (specifically, the passion for inventing) in driving learning and innovation within the NPD process. The practical implications of these findings are significant for high-tech ventures seeking to enhance their NPD outcomes. Specifically, cultivating an organizational culture that perceives failure as an opportunity for learning, coupled with recognizing and fostering the passion for inventing among NPD project leaders, can boost NPD product innovativeness.
Practitioner Points:
- Promote an organizational culture that views failure as a learning opportunity rather than a setback. This normalization of failure fosters an environment where employees may be more willing to experiment and innovate in the new product development (NPD) process.
- Select project leaders with passion for inventing. Leaders with a deep passion for inventing are more inclined to learn from failures, thereby enhancing the innovativeness of NPD projects in failure tolerant environments.
- Develop a work environment that both normalizes failure and values the passion for inventing. This dual approach enables high-tech ventures to make the most of learning from failure in cultures that normalize failure, thereby significantly enhancing NPD product innovativeness.