kHUB All Member Forum

 View Only

The Empathy Trap: Why Focusing Only on Customers Holds Your Product Back

By Keyuri Anand posted 2 days ago

  
The Empathy Trap: Why Focusing Only on Customers Holds Your Product Back

The Empathy Trap: Why Focusing Only on Customers Holds Your Product Back

Read Time: 7 minutes

By Parul Jain (SF Chapter) and Keyuri Anand (Texas Chapter)

Empathy isn’t new to product managers. It’s often one of the first things they learn: understand users, uncover needs, and build experiences that make life better. But somewhere along the way, customer empathy became a trap. Product managers became so focused on customers that they lost sight of the larger system that keeps a product alive.

Great products need more than customer insight. They need alignment across business goals, leadership expectations, technical realities, and organizational priorities. Product managers who make the effort to understand what drives everyone involved, from business teams to designers, build products that last and careers that grow with them.

Customer empathy helps you start. Organizational empathy helps you keep going. 


The Limits of Customer Empathy

Early in a product career, empathy usually means getting closer to customers. You interview users, study behavior, and look for pain points to solve. It’s a great foundation, but it can also create tunnel vision. When every decision is filtered only through the customer’s voice, it’s easy to forget that a product lives inside a business.

As a product manager grows, the role becomes about balance. You still care deeply about users, but you also need to think about how the product supports company goals, fits within technical capacity, and aligns with the people building it.

A feature that delights users but drains resources might not survive long. A product that grows engagement but hurts margins eventually loses support. The challenge isn’t choosing between customers and the business; it’s connecting both in a way that keeps the product healthy over time.

Customer empathy helps you see what people want. Organizational empathy helps you see what makes it possible.


The Shift From Customer Empathy to Organizational Empathy

As product managers move up in the hierarchy, the job starts to look different. It’s no longer only about fixing user problems. The work shifts toward connecting what customers need with what the other stakeholders are trying to achieve.

That’s where organizational empathy becomes important. It’s about really paying attention to how different groups think and what pressures they face. Engineers worry about precision and scale. Finance wants predictability. Designers focus on experience and usability. Business looks for growth and return. None of these views is wrong, but together they can pull a product in competing directions.

When product managers slow down enough to understand those perspectives, alignment feels easier. It’s no longer about defending your roadmap. It’s about finding a path that connects everyone’s goals. That kind of awareness helps you decide what to build, how to measure impact, and how to talk about value in a way that makes sense to everyone at the table.

Customer empathy helps build the right product. Organizational empathy helps it succeed. 


Empathy as a Business Skill

Empathy isn’t about being emotional. It’s the information, context that helps you make smarter business decisions.

When engineering hesitates to adopt a new architecture, it isn’t resistance, it’s the protection of resources. When finance pushes back on an idea, it isn’t a lack of vision, it’s risk management. When marketing asks for measurable results, it isn’t vanity, it’s accountability.

Noticing these patterns turns tension into insight. It helps you design solutions that meet real needs without breaking financial or operational boundaries.

Strong product managers learn to switch lenses often, from customer outcomes to business metrics, from usability to profitability. They understand that empathy without commercial awareness doesn’t scale. A product lasts only when it creates value for both customers and the business.

But understanding the business side of empathy is only half the work. The harder part is using it across the organization and aligning people who see the same problem through very different perspectives. That’s where organizational empathy comes in. It helps product managers move from influencing outcomes to shaping how decisions get made in the first place.


Reading the Room

Most alignment issues in product management don’t come from a lack of data or process. They come from people seeing the same goal through different lenses. Engineers, designers, business teams, and leaders each have their own version of success, and they’re often all right in their own way.

Reading the room is the skill that helps product managers turn those different perspectives into forward motion. It’s about noticing tone, questions that don’t get asked, or the silence that follows a decision. Empathy helps you sense when there’s hesitation or confusion, even when no one says it out loud.

The goal isn’t to avoid conflict but to understand what’s behind it. Once you see what’s really creating tension, you can reframe the conversation and bring people back to the shared goal. That awareness turns a difficult meeting into a productive one, and often, that’s what keeps a product moving.

When people feel understood, they collaborate. When they feel ignored, they defend. Empathy is how you move from opposition to ownership.


Empathy with Borders

Empathy doesn’t mean saying yes to everyone. It means understanding where people are coming from and still making the calls based on your product judgment.

Many product managers, especially early in their careers, confuse empathy with agreement. They want to maintain harmony, so they take on too much or avoid tough conversations. But empathy without boundaries leads to confusion. Teams need clarity more than consensus.

Good product leaders listen carefully, gather context, and then decide with confidence. They explain the trade-offs and show that every view was considered, even if not every request made it in. That balance of care and conviction builds trust over time. Empathy earns respect when it’s paired with direction.

Listening shows you care. Acting with clarity shows you lead.


Learning How Others Think

Empathy lands best when people see that you’ve taken the time to understand how they think. You can’t build alignment if you don’t understand the lens others are using to make decisions.

Good product managers stay curious about the world around them. They learn how engineers balance precision with speed, how finance evaluates return, how design defines quality, and how leadership measures success. Speaking their language shows that you respect their expertise and care about the same outcomes they do.

This kind of understanding makes your decisions easier to explain. It turns “we can’t” into “here’s why it’s tough right now and what we can try instead.” When people feel seen and understood, they stop treating discussions as negotiations and start working with you to find a solution.

Empathy without understanding feels empty. Understanding turns it into trust.


What Product Leaders Know

With experience, product managers learn that empathy is not a goal on its own. It’s a way to understand people and systems so you can make better decisions.

Successful product leaders connect what customers need with what the business can sustain and what the team can deliver. They read the room, notice tension early, and use that awareness to guide conversations before problems grow.

Over time, product leaders realize empathy is just a lens. It helps you navigate both people and performance.

Here are a few reminders that keep empathy productive:

  • Empathy helps you interpret signals, not absorb stress.
  • Business context gives empathy direction.
  • Metrics validate empathy by showing its impact.
  • Understanding the system is as important as understanding the user.
  • Clarity, not compromise, is what makes empathy valuable.

Empathy helps you see the full picture. Conviction helps you move it forward. The best leaders use both.


Leading with Empathy and Intent

Empathy is what connects product managers to people. Intent is what turns that connection into action. When both work together, they create products and teams that last.

Empathy without direction can leave teams stuck in understanding. Direction without empathy can leave them moving but disconnected. The balance between the two is what defines real product leadership.

So, as you grow in your career, ask yourself, are you only listening to your customers, or are you also understanding the system that helps you serve them?

Are you building a product or are you growing a company?

ABOUT THE AUTHORS

Parul Jain

Parul Jain is a Product Strategy Leader with over a decade of experience driving AI-led innovation and digital transformation across telecommunications, mobility, fintech, retail, and e-commerce. She currently serves as the Vice President of Programming for the PDMA SF Bay Area Chapter, supporting thought leadership and continuous learning within the product community.

Parul actively contributes to the advancement of product management and innovation through mentoring emerging product leaders, advising startups, authoring thought-leadership content on AI and product strategy, and participating as a judge for product and innovation awards. She holds a Master of Science in Product Management from Carnegie Mellon University and a Bachelor’s in Electronics and Communication Engineering.

Keyuri Andand

Keyuri Anand is a globally recognized product leader specializing in AI product management, with a focus on scalable enterprise innovation and AI workforce enablement. Over the past 12+ years, she has led high-impact product initiatives at companies including SAP, Guidewire, and Clio, building and scaling AI-powered platforms used by Fortune 500 clients, government institutions and global organizations. Her work has directly influenced the evolution of intelligent legal systems, enterprise billing automation, and humanitarian AI applications.

Keyuri currently serves as the Founder and President of the PDMA Texas Chapter. She is also a member of the PDMA Body of Knowledge Editorial Board, helping shape the global standards for product innovation and certification. A passionate speaker and educator, she has taught AI for Leaders at UT Austin and AI Product Management at Johns Hopkins University and has trained 1000s of product professionals through programs like Maven and JoinColab.

Related Content

#ProductManagement #ProductLeadership #EmpathyInProduct #OrgEmpathy #StakeholderAlignment #ProductStrategy #CrossFunctionalCollaboration #ProductLifecycle #BuildTheRightThing #DoingTheRightThingsRight #DecisionMaking #PMCareerGrowth


#ProductInnovationManagement
#PortfolioManagement
#Culture,TeamsandLeadership

0 comments
6 views

Permalink